Intention stalls. Not dramatically, more awkwardly: an artefact masters the technique and refuses the form. Lupu (2026) starts precisely there and treats the stalling not as romantic vagueness but as a condition of method.
In Melissanthi Spei’s studio, a pre-planned ethnography with observation, interviews, sound and image meets a piece that will not resolve. The designer steps back, works on other things and returns. The piece is neither success nor failure. It is an impasse, and this impasse redirects the inquiry instead of ending up as an error report.
For Lupu, uncertainty is not a knowledge gap waiting to be closed. It is a resource, on three levels. In method, it means holding categories back. In material, it means taking seriously what materials do and what they refuse to do. At root, it means that human and thing cannot be neatly separated. New materialism supplies the frame; practice supplies the break. Hybrid textile practices and new materials need tools that keep pace with this thinking.
Many methods want to pin down what they study. Lupu takes up Stengers’ critique of capture here: methods that work this way tame the very uncertainty they set out to study. In terms of method, this means the categories come out of the work, not before it.
In hindsight the path reads clearly: documenting, dwelling, re-reading, returning. The turning point is the encounter with what resists description. Affective materiality, intuition and emplacedness do not show up as labels but as concepts born of dissonance: the balance tips, there is technique without form and form without balance. Creative writing circles the relationship to the piece instead of cataloguing it. Blind drawing gives the designer back a different register: the memory of weight and texture instead of an image. The drawing shifts the relationship to the piece without resolving it. Closure here means a changed encounter and an offering to the practice, not a resolved form and extracted data. The piece remains unresolved. The research may end anyway.
Impasse is the moment when intention shows its limit. The material resists and halts a project instead of carrying it. Lupu deliberately sets this against the many stories of successful collaboration with material: frustration and postponement, and still the piece stays in the room. Holding intention back does not mean having no stance. It means no longer believing that intention writes alone. Where neither researcher nor practitioner knows what they are encountering, there is no embarrassing moment in the record, but a privileged site of research.
For SOL LAB, the bridge lies with Probe and Between, not with the gloss of the final submission. A cast with a bubble, glass with an intervention, a textile with an unresolved remainder: a probe like this is not an interim state on the way to the finished specification. It shows that form co-writes before the intention is fully formulated. Tolerating uncertainty, leaving the stubborn piece on the table and coming back with another means, a drawing, a note, a second cast: that is studio work, not a methods showcase.
Which question in your work may stall right now, and which closure would merely be capture?
Sources
Lupu, R. (2026). Material Impasse: Decentering Intentionality through Uncertainty in Textile Craft. In J. Scott, S. Skach, & R. Stewart (Eds.), Textile Intersections 2026 (London, 17–18 September 2026). Design Research Society. https://doi.org/10.21606/TI-2026.132